What Type of Milk is Best for Making Yogurt at Home? FREE Comparison Chart

By | January 20, 2023
A glass jar filled with homemade yogurt, with a white spoon on the side

A delicious serving of homemade yogurt, perfect for a snack!

Milk TypeSensory QualitiesRating
Cow’s MilkVisual – Opaque and smooth; Aroma – Sweet, milky scent; Taste – Mild and subtly sweet; Oral Processing – Creamy yet light texture; Gustation – Lingering sweetness.★★★★
Goat’s MilkVisual – Pale yellow hue; Aroma – Subtle, earthy scent; Taste – Nutty flavor with a hint of sweetness; Oral Processing – Rich yet lightweight consistency; Gustation – Pleasant aftertaste.★★★★
Soy MilkVisual – Pale and milky; Aroma – Nutty, slightly sweet scent; Taste – Light yet nutty flavor; Oral Processing – Smooth and creamy texture; Gustation – Pleasant aftertaste.★★★
Almond MilkVisual – Pale and creamy; Aroma – Sweet, nutty scent; Taste – Delicately sweet flavor; Oral Processing – Lightweight yet creamy consistency; Gustation – Lingering sweetness.★★★★
Oat MilkVisual – Smooth and creamy; Aroma – Mild, oaty scent; Taste – Subtly sweet with oaty notes; Oral Processing – Rich yet light texture; Gustation – Pleasant aftertaste.★★★★
Coconut MilkVisual – Opaque and silky; Aroma – Sweet, coconut scent; Taste – Mildly sweet and nutty flavor; Oral Processing – Thick yet light consistency; Gustation – Lingering sweetness.★★★★


Choosing the type of milk for making yogurt is like going on a treasure hunt; you must seek out the perfect blend that will yield a delicious, creamy reward.

Making yogurt at home offers a delicious opportunity to customize your favorite treat. When it comes to choosing the type of milk you’ll use as your base, there are a few things to keep in mind.

Firstly, you should consider what type of yogurt you’d like to make. Traditional yoghurt typically requires whole or homogenized milk, while a lighter variety like greek yoghurt often calls for low-fat or skimmed cow’s milk. Coconut, almond and soy milks can also be used to make vegan alternatives, such as coconut yogurt.

When it comes to setting up your yogurt-making station at home, you’ll need a few basic supplies: sealed containers, parchment paper, plastic wrap, a heat-proof seal or towel (e.g. cheesecloth), and a temperature controlled device such as an electric yogurt cooker or slow cooker.

Once you’ve gathered your supplies, it’s time to prepare the milk. If you’re using coconut milk, simply thaw it out and mix in a couple of tablespoons of honey for sweetness. If you’re opting for cow’s milk, heat it up to just below boiling point before letting it cool down – approximately 40°C or 105°F is ideal.

The key ingredient for making yogurt is active, live cultures. You can find these in store-bought yogurt products, or buy dedicated starter cultures specifically for homemade yogurt. Once added to the warm milk, it’s time to let the mixture sit wrapped up in a towel and stored away from direct light – this should take around 8 hours depending on the temperature of your kitchen.

The next step involves transferring the yogurt to the refrigerator, where it should be allowed to cool and set for a few more hours until it reaches your desired consistency. Once cooled, you’ll have a creamy, light and delicious homemade yogurt that your family won’t be able to resist! Enjoy as-is or add extra ingredients like fresh fruit, seeds or nuts for a truly unique and tasty treat.

Making your own yogurt from scratch may seem daunting at first, but with the right ingredients and equipment, it’s actually super simple. Whether you’re looking for a traditional taste or something exotic like coconut yogurt – all you need is a little patience and you’ll be rewarded with a delicious product in no time! So why not give it a go and see for yourself just how easy it is to make your own yogurt at home? You won’t regret it.